As a child of parents who had decided to reject their own parents' and society's religious traditions with the belief that they were ushering in a new era of peace, love and understanding, (...dawning of the age of Aquarius, and so forth) one thing that can be accurately said about me is that I was not raised religiously. This sets me apart from most people I know in that I seem not to share a common set of references that those who were raised with the pressures of religious tradition have. ...even when they were raised in vastly different religious cultures.
One might think that that would make me hostile to religion in general (or at the very least, indifferent) but quite the opposite. Not having had the pressures of an almighty religion to instill silly and irrational fears in me as a child or the disillusion of seeing the world fall short of some grand religious ideal... this actually enabled me to develop a healthy and balanced curiosity about the subject and throughout my life as I explored the traditions and texts of the different major religions I invariably found the same thing: Tremendous wisdom and advice on how to live together harmoniously and be spiritually fulfilled, mixed with quaint, archaic and obsolete notions that obviously only made sense in the contexts they were thought up in. But always, I find the wisdom far outweighs the silliness...
I also see in religion one of the best and most successful human enterprises to create and foster social cohesion on a large scale and as such, it has been one of the main forces behind the success of civilization (large numbers of people living in close proximity without hating and killing each other) I know that there are many people who ardently argue the opposite, that religious fanaticism has been the main cause of most violence throughout history... or at least that it's behind the worst violence today.
But I've also noticed that all of the most strident critics of religion (Dawkins, Harris, ...even Bill Maher, who I really like otherwise) seem to have suffered from having been raised in somewhat overbearing religious environments - and you often get the feeling that they're just really pissed off at something in their childhood.
And besides, to blame religion for fanaticism is simply to ignore the evil that lives in men's hearts. Fanaticism is not a product of religion but of human nature. (Just think of all the death, destruction and violence caused by communist, capitalist or fascist ideological fanaticism throughout the last century)... Humans start to think fanatically when they feel threatened... think of it, we all do. If we fear the current rise in religious fanaticism that seems to characterize the dawn of the current century, we should try to understand what makes many Muslims of the world, many religious and traditional Americans, and here at home, people like the folks of Hérouxville feel so threatened. I'm not saying that the threats these groups perceive to themselves are all legitimate, ...or even real, but it is only by being aware of them that we can hope to make any headway. To simply blame their fanaticism on backward religious beliefs is to delude ourselves and compound the problem.
That being said, we of the so called "enlightened" classes also feel threatened by religious fanaticism and as such we tend to retreat into our own comforting, uninformed, borderline-fanatical beliefs.
Beliefs like: "Islam oppresses women"
My fellow MySpace blogger and friend
Umit sheds some
much needed light on this belief in her blog.
[Update: For reasons of her own, she now sets her blog to 'private' but her post is still available on another blog site]
Read it carefully, imagine this in the context of 6th century Arab(!) culture. After which I challenge you not to see in the birth of Islam a radically progressive and pro-woman agenda.
Note to western christian-raised folks:
Like me, most of you aren't particularly religious and yet recognize the inherent goodness and wisdom behind the christian message while brushing over the inconvenient parts that have been used to incite violence in our history. I assure you that if you take a look at the Koran, you'll find that it espouses and promotes virtually the same values as Christianity and that the less convenient parts that can be used to incite violence are pretty much of the same nature as what can be found in the new testament.Labels: Age of Aquarius, Bill Maher, Dawkins, Fanaticism, Harris, Islam, Religion, Violence, Women